Fatherland (dir. Pawel Pawlikowski)

By: Adam Freed


There is certainly nothing wrong with a patient film, so long as it offers sufficient payoff in exchange for the investment it asks of its audience.  In the case of Fatherland, a post-WWII exploration of an oft-ignored period in German history in which the nation was left in economic and physical ruin by the corrosive nature of Hitler’s Third Reich, there is plenty of runway and very little destination of which to speak.  Pawel Pawlikowski (Ida, Cold War) directs the gorgeously rendered black and white film as it follows acclaimed German writer Thomas Mann and his adult daughter Erika, as they traverse what is left of their native land at the brink of the Cold War.  


Pawlikowski’s dialogue-heavy German language film underdelivers on two considerable opportunities as it explores the relationship between the laudable father and his dutiful daughter.  The first is the underutilization of Sandra Hüller (Anatomy of a Fall, Project Hail Mary) whose Erika is infused with a patient stoicism that never fully melts through its icy exterior to reveal the immense magnitude of Hüller’s range.  The second oversight that Fatherland commits is that it fails to allow audiences to simply exist within a time and place so remote and divergent from the 21st Century.  The occasional image of a city block in ruin or depiction of what remains of a once majestic architectural feat, are mere tastes of what could’ve been a deliciously informative visual meal.  While limiting visual access to the post-war destruction is very likely an intentional decision, it is one that builds a barrier for audiences rather than acting as an invitation to experience the realities of the war to end all wars.  The result of this pair of missteps is an 80 minute film that feels much longer, and the relegation of a fascinating time in global history into the realm of feeling rote.


Target Score 6/10 - For all of its promise, Pawel Pawlikowski’s Fatherland is an overly still, underdelivered dive into post-war German history.  Underrepresenting the visual impact that the war had on the once gorgeous region is forgivable in this family drama, underutilizing the limitless potential of Sandra Hüller is not.


This special presentation of Fatherland is included in Movie Archer’s coverage of the 62nd Chicago International Film Festival